The Future of Truth by Werner Herzog: Deep Wisdom or Playful Prank?
As an octogenarian, the celebrated director is considered a enduring figure who operates entirely on his own terms. Similar to his unusual and enchanting cinematic works, the director's latest publication challenges standard norms of storytelling, merging the distinctions between truth and invention while examining the essential nature of truth itself.
A Concise Book on Authenticity in a Modern World
Herzog's newest offering details the filmmaker's opinions on authenticity in an era dominated by technology-enhanced deceptions. These ideas appear to be an expansion of Herzog's earlier declaration from the turn of the century, featuring strong, gnomic beliefs that include criticizing cinéma vérité for hiding more than it clarifies to surprising statements such as "choose mortality before a wig".
Core Principles of Herzog's Authenticity
A pair of essential ideas form his understanding of truth. First is the belief that chasing truth is more valuable than actually finding it. According to him puts it, "the journey alone, bringing us nearer the concealed truth, enables us to participate in something essentially unattainable, which is truth". Additionally is the belief that bare facts deliver little more than a uninspiring "financial statement truth" that is less helpful than what he terms "rapturous reality" in assisting people understand life's deeper meanings.
If anyone else had authored The Future of Truth, I imagine they would face critical fire for teasing from the reader
Italy's Porcine: An Allegorical Tale
Reading the book resembles attending a campfire speech from an engaging uncle. Among several fascinating tales, the strangest and most memorable is the tale of the Palermo pig. In the filmmaker, long ago a swine got trapped in a vertical waste conduit in the Sicilian city, Sicily. The pig stayed wedged there for a long time, surviving on scraps of sustenance tossed to it. Eventually the pig took on the contours of its container, transforming into a kind of translucent block, "ethereally white ... shaky like a big chunk of Jello", receiving food from above and eliminating refuse below.
From Pipes to Planets
The author uses this story as an metaphor, connecting the Sicilian swine to the perils of extended cosmic journeys. Should humanity undertake a journey to our closest inhabitable world, it would need generations. Over this time Herzog foresees the brave voyagers would be obliged to inbreed, becoming "mutants" with little awareness of their expedition's objective. Ultimately the cosmic explorers would change into light-colored, larval entities rather like the trapped animal, able of little more than consuming and defecating.
Ecstatic Truth vs Factual Reality
This disturbingly compelling and unintentionally hilarious transition from Sicilian sewers to interstellar freaks presents a lesson in Herzog's concept of rapturous reality. As audience members might find to their astonishment after trying to confirm this intriguing and biologically implausible geometric animal, the Italian hog seems to be apocryphal. The pursuit for the miserly "literal veracity", a existence grounded in mere facts, overlooks the point. Why was it important whether an confined Mediterranean livestock actually transformed into a shaking gelatinous cube? The real lesson of Herzog's tale unexpectedly becomes clear: penning animals in small spaces for prolonged times is imprudent and produces monsters.
Unique Musings and Critical Reception
If another writer had authored The Future of Truth, they could encounter severe judgment for unusual structural choices, meandering statements, contradictory ideas, and, honestly, taking the piss out of the reader. In the end, Herzog devotes several sections to the theatrical storyline of an opera just to demonstrate that when art forms include powerful emotion, we "channel this ridiculous essence with the entire spectrum of our own feeling, so that it appears mysteriously authentic". Nevertheless, since this volume is a collection of uniquely Herzogian thoughts, it avoids negative reviews. The sparkling and creative translation from the native tongue – where a legendary animal expert is described as "lacking full mental capacity" – remarkably makes Herzog increasingly unique in style.
Deepfakes and Current Authenticity
Although much of The Future of Truth will be known from his earlier books, films and discussions, one somewhat fresh component is his meditation on deepfakes. The author points multiple times to an computer-created endless discussion between artificial voice replicas of the author and a fellow philosopher online. Since his own methods of achieving ecstatic truth have involved creating quotes by prominent individuals and selecting performers in his non-fiction films, there exists a potential of hypocrisy. The difference, he contends, is that an thinking individual would be adequately capable to recognize {lies|false